2016/2017 Archive: Who Selected: Astrology
| # | Team |
| 1 | bay ridge boys |
| 2 | Big B |
| 3 | Black Math |
| 4 | BornLucky |
| 5 | Castella |
| 6 | Fighting Irish |
| 7 | Hot Peppers No Onions |
| 8 | Keggers |
| 9 | King of Pain |
| 10 | Luv Ya Blue |
| 11 | Madoff's Misery |
| 12 | Mudd Doggs |
| 13 | NY Pinstripes |
| 14 | Peterrabbit |
| 15 | thirteenfive |
| 16 | Znark's |